Free Appeal Kit For HMRC Decisions: Outline Letters, Deadlines And Checklists
A free kit for appealing an HMRC decision or penalty: the deadlines in one table, outline letters for an appeal, a review, a reasonable excuse and a late appeal, notes on the tribunal's form T240, a grounds outline and a hearing checklist.
If you have an HMRC decision or penalty in front of you and are weighing an appeal, this kit is a pack to work from, printed or on screen. Each section links to our fuller guide.
Your deadline: for most decisions, 30 days from the date printed on the letter, not the day it arrived; count that date as day one to be safe. For income tax, capital gains tax, corporation tax and National Insurance, the 30 days are for appealing to HMRC. For VAT and other indirect taxes, they are for appealing to the tribunal or accepting the review HMRC offer. Some decisions have other time limits, and your letter should state yours. The law sets the limit, not the letter: if the two seem to differ, work to the earlier date.
If time is short, you can appeal within the 30 days with brief reasons and send details and evidence later. A letter you can appeal says so, usually under "Your rights" or "How to appeal" (which letters can be appealed).
This kit is general information about the law and procedure, not legal or tax advice on your situation: it can't tell you whether to appeal or what to argue. This site is independent and is not part of, or connected with, HMRC, HM Courts & Tribunals Service or the tribunal, and the outlines are not official forms. For help with your own case, see Where To Get Free Help below.
Deadlines, addresses and phone numbers checked 12 November 2026.
In this kit: deadlines, outline letters, the notice of appeal, grounds of appeal, hearing checklist and free help.
Deadlines At A Glance
Each period runs from the date printed on the letter named, unless the tables say otherwise. Using the wrong route can lead to an appeal being struck out.
Direct Taxes: Income Tax, Capital Gains Tax, Corporation Tax And National Insurance
| Step | What happens |
|---|---|
| First appeal | To HMRC in writing, within 30 days of the decision letter; never straight to the tribunal |
| Review | After appealing, you can ask for one until HMRC offer one or you notify your appeal to the tribunal. HMRC's offer comes with their view: within 30 days of that letter, accept it or notify your appeal to the tribunal, or your appeal is treated as settled on HMRC's view |
| HMRC's time for a review | 45 days, beginning with the day HMRC receive your acceptance (or, for a review you asked for, give you their view), or longer if you agree. If they run out of time, the decision is treated as upheld |
| Tribunal after a review | Within 30 days of the review conclusion letter. If HMRC run out of time, you can go from the end of their 45 days until 30 days after their letter saying so: don't wait for that letter |
| Tribunal without a review | After appealing to HMRC, until they offer a review or reply with their view to your request for one; after an offer, within its 30 days |
| A penalty | Its own 30 days from the date of the penalty notice, separate from the tax decision; the appeal goes to HMRC |
| If you are late | First appeal: HMRC must accept it if you ask in writing and they are satisfied you had a reasonable excuse and asked without unreasonable delay once it ended; if they refuse, ask the tribunal. A missed review offer: HMRC's guidance applies the same test; otherwise, the tribunal's permission. After a review: the tribunal's permission only |
VAT And Other Indirect Taxes
| Step | What happens |
|---|---|
| First appeal | To the tribunal within 30 days of the decision letter, unless you accept the review it offers |
| Review | Offered in the decision letter: accept within 30 days of it, or appeal to the tribunal instead |
| HMRC's time for a review | 45 days, beginning with the day HMRC receive your acceptance, or longer if you agree. If they run out of time, the decision is treated as upheld |
| Tribunal after a review | Within 30 days of the review conclusion letter. If HMRC run out of time, you can go from the end of their 45 days until 30 days after their letter saying so: don't wait for that letter |
| Tribunal without a review | Within 30 days of the decision letter |
| A penalty | Its own 30 days from the date of the penalty letter, which offers a review: accept it or appeal to the tribunal |
| If you are late | Only with the tribunal's permission, unless you first ask HMRC in writing for a review out of time, which they must carry out if they are satisfied you had a reasonable excuse and asked without unreasonable delay once it ended |
Paying while you appeal. An appeal doesn't stop income tax, capital gains tax or corporation tax being due: to postpone the amount you dispute, apply to HMRC in writing within 30 days of the date the assessment, amendment or closure notice was issued, saying how much you think you are overcharged and why. If HMRC refuse, you can refer your application to the tribunal within 30 days of their decision letter. A National Insurance decision has no formal postponement, but you can ask HMRC to hold collection back. For VAT, customs and excise, see hardship. Penalties don't normally have to be paid while you appeal them, but if the appeal fails, interest runs on the penalty from the date it was due, as it does on any tax you turn out to owe (postponing payment).
Seized goods have different routes, with one deadline of just one month (customs seizure appeals). The law: sections 31A and 49 to 49I TMA 1970 for income tax and capital gains tax, and sections 83A to 83G VATA 1994 for VAT.
Outline Letters
These show what each kind of letter usually contains, with prompts in square brackets. They are not forms and there is no required wording: use your own words, leave out what doesn't apply, and stick to facts you can support. Each goes to HMRC, at the address on their letter or through their online service where the letter offers one; an appeal to the tribunal goes on the notice of appeal instead. Keep a copy, with proof of posting.
Outline 1: An Appeal To HMRC Against A Direct-Tax Decision
For an appealable direct-tax decision, such as an assessment, amendment, closure notice or penalty, within 30 days of the decision letter (appeal rights guide). It usually contains:
- Your details: [your name and address], [your UTR, National Insurance number or other tax reference] and [HMRC's reference]. Why: HMRC match your letter to your record by these.
- A plain statement that you appeal against [the decision] dated [the date of HMRC's decision letter]. Why: the law requires notice of appeal in writing (section 31A TMA 1970); an informal request to reconsider isn't one, and the time keeps running.
- Each decision appealed: [the kind of decision], [the tax year, such as the 2023/24 tax year], [the amount] and [the date of the letter]. Why: if one letter holds an assessment and penalties, grounds that only address the assessment leave the penalties standing.
- Your grounds: [numbered points saying what HMRC got wrong (a fact, a figure or the law they applied), and the evidence you have or can get]. Why: the notice must "specify the grounds of appeal", but no set format or legal language is needed (outline below).
- The outcome you seek: [such as cancelling the assessment, or reducing it to [the figure you say is right]]. Why: the tribunal requires it if the case gets there.
- A postponement request, for disputed tax: [that you apply under section 55 TMA 1970 to postpone [the amount you believe is overcharged], and why]. Why: without it the tax stays payable (see paying while you appeal).
- A review request, if you want one now. Why: you can ask in this letter, later or not at all (Outline 2).
- Enclosures, signature and date. Why: it records what you sent and when.
Outline 2: Asking For, Or Accepting, An HMRC Review
A statutory review is a free, fresh look at the decision by an HMRC officer not involved in it, which upholds, varies or cancels it. For a direct-tax decision you have appealed to HMRC, or a VAT or other indirect-tax decision whose letter offers a review. An offer must be accepted within 30 days of the letter making it (review guide). It usually contains:
- Your details, with [the date of your appeal to HMRC, for direct tax] and [the date of any letter offering a review].
- A plain statement: [that you accept HMRC's offer of a review of their decision dated [date]], or [that you ask HMRC to review their decision dated [date], which you appealed on [date]]. Why: this is what starts the review.
- Why you disagree: [your grounds, with anything new since your appeal, including your answer to the reasons in HMRC's letter]. Why: the reviewing officer reads the case fresh.
- Supporting documents, listed.
You can't run a review and a tribunal appeal at the same time; the table shows the deadlines.
Outline 3: A Penalty Appeal On The Ground Of Reasonable Excuse
For a penalty for a late return or payment, or a failure to notify that wasn't deliberate, within 30 days of the penalty notice. Direct-tax penalties are appealed to HMRC (for a Self Assessment late filing or payment penalty, GOV.UK's online service or form SA370 can replace a letter); a VAT penalty letter offers a review or a tribunal appeal (reasonable excuse; illness and mental health). Under the points-based regime for VAT and Making Tax Digital for Income Tax, each late submission point can be appealed too, within 30 days of its notice; if you miss that, you can still challenge earlier points when you appeal a penalty.
A reasonable excuse is something that stopped you meeting the obligation and that a reasonable person in your position would accept as a valid reason. It must exist at the deadline, and once it ends you must put things right without unreasonable delay. The letter usually contains:
- Your details.
- Each penalty: [the kind of penalty], [the tax year or VAT period], [the amount] and [the date of each penalty notice]. Why: penalties issued at different times each have their own 30 days.
- What happened, in date order: [the circumstances, and when they began and ended]. Why: the excuse must exist at the deadline.
- How it stopped you filing, paying or dealing with HMRC in time. Why: what decides it is whether the circumstances stopped you, not only that they happened.
- What you did once it ended: [the date you filed, paid or, for a failure to notify, told HMRC]. Why: tribunals have generally expected days or a few weeks, not months.
- Anyone you relied on: [who, what you asked them to do and how you checked]. Why: relying on someone else isn't a reasonable excuse unless you took reasonable care.
- Your evidence, listed, with anything still to come. Why: proving the excuse is for you, on the balance of probabilities (more likely than not).
- Some letters add an alternative: [a request that, if HMRC don't accept the excuse, they reduce the penalty because of special circumstances]. Why: HMRC can do that even without an excuse, though not for inability to pay; under the new penalty regime, late submission points and penalties can't be reduced this way.
- The outcome you seek: [that the penalty is cancelled].
HMRC's guidance says these aren't reasonable excuses on their own: lack of money (the law allows it only if caused by events outside your control), finding HMRC's systems difficult, not getting a reminder, or a mistake on your return.
Evidence Checklist For A Reasonable Excuse
No law requires medical evidence for an illness, but it is the strongest kind, and claims without it have failed.
- A dated timeline from the deadline to the day you filed, paid or told HMRC.
- Letters, emails, appointment or hospital letters, and notes of calls with HMRC.
- Illness: a letter from a doctor, mental health professional or social care professional covering the dates from the deadline until you acted, and how your condition affected your ability to deal with your affairs then, not just now. HMRC also accept one from a voluntary organisation, such as Citizens Advice or TaxAid, that has satisfied itself from such a source.
- A computer or online service failure: screenshots. Postal problems: proof of posting.
- Relying on someone: what you gave them, when, and how you followed up.
- Your own written account, and accounts from anyone with direct knowledge of what happened.
- If something doesn't exist, a line saying so and offering what does: HMRC's guidance tells officers to be prepared to accept alternatives.
Outline 4: Asking HMRC To Accept A Late Appeal
For a direct-tax decision you didn't appeal to HMRC within the 30 days. HMRC must accept a late appeal if you ask in writing and they are satisfied you had a reasonable excuse and asked without unreasonable delay once it ended (section 49 TMA 1970); if they refuse, you can ask the tribunal (late appeals guide). Each day of delay makes a late appeal harder. It usually contains:
- Your details.
- The decision: [what HMRC decided], [the date of the decision letter] and [the date the 30 days ended]. Why: the length of the delay is the starting point.
- The request: [that HMRC accept your notice of appeal late, under section 49 TMA 1970].
- Why you were late, with dates. Why: this is the reasonable excuse HMRC must be satisfied of.
- What changed, and when: [when the reason ended and what you have done since]. Why: HMRC must also be satisfied you then asked without unreasonable delay.
- The appeal itself: [your grounds, as in Outline 1]. Why: if it reaches the tribunal, the strength of your case is part of what it weighs.
- A postponement request, for disputed tax. Why: the usual 30-day limit doesn't apply once a late appeal is accepted, but nothing is postponed before then.
- Evidence for the delay: [medical letters, correspondence, proof of posting].
At the tribunal, a late notice of appeal must ask for permission and give the reasons for the delay. The tribunal weighs how serious the delay was, why it happened and all the circumstances, giving particular importance to the need to respect time limits. Other late cases are in the table.
The Tribunal's Notice Of Appeal
You appeal, or notify an appeal, to the First-tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber) online through GOV.UK's appeal page, or on form T240 sent by email to taxappeals@justice.gov.uk or by post to First-tier Tribunal (Tax), PO Box 16972, Birmingham, B16 6TZ. It goes to the tribunal, not HMRC, and must arrive in time. There is no fee. The tribunal's own guidance is the T242, and its helpline, 0300 303 5857 (Monday to Friday, 9am to 4pm), explains the process but "cannot give you legal advice" (T240 guide).
For VAT and other indirect taxes, this is your appeal. For direct taxes, it notifies the tribunal of an appeal you have already made to HMRC (the table shows when). Send that appeal first and wait until you can confirm HMRC have it: appeals have been struck out because the tribunal received the notice before HMRC received the appeal.
What The Tribunal Asks For
Online or on paper, you are asked for:
- your name, address and an address for documents (the tribunal writes by email if you have one);
- any representative's details;
- each decision: what it is about and the amounts in dispute (give its date and reference too, so the tribunal can match it to the letter you attach);
- for direct tax, whether you appealed to HMRC first and whether HMRC said you were late;
- your grounds, with reasons for each decision, and the result you want in two or three sentences;
- why you didn't appeal earlier: the current paper form asks everyone this, even if in time; if you are late, add a request for permission and your reasons, without which the tribunal must not admit the appeal;
- any support you need at a hearing (ask for an interpreter in a covering note);
- a statement of truth.
A non-lawyer representative needs your signature on the T240 or a signed form T239; the tribunal then writes to them, not you.
What To Attach
- HMRC's decision letter, and any review conclusion letter: the tribunal can't see HMRC's files.
- Your grounds on a separate sheet if the box is too small, with your name on each sheet.
- Anything that directly supports a key ground or explains lateness. The rest of your evidence comes later, on the tribunal's timetable.
A form with anything missing is returned, and may be late by the time you resend it. If you have lost the decision letter, ask HMRC for a copy, enclose what you have, and explain why it is missing.
Indirect Taxes: Paying First, Or Hardship
If your appeal is about VAT that HMRC say you owe, the tribunal can't hear it until the VAT is paid or deposited, unless HMRC or, if they refuse, the tribunal accept that paying would cause you hardship (section 84 VATA 1994). Customs and excise duty have a similar rule, with security as another option. A penalty or surcharge itself doesn't have to be paid first, but any VAT behind it that HMRC say is due does, unless hardship is accepted.
You can file in time without waiting for HMRC's answer on hardship, saying your application is pending (the form's Section 4 asks); if HMRC have refused, include your application to the tribunal. Interest and penalties keep building up on unpaid VAT. Postponing direct tax is a separate application to HMRC, not part of the T240 (postponement and the hardship test).
Your Case Category
The tribunal allocates your case to a category when it receives your notice of appeal; either side can ask for a change.
| Category | Typical cases | What happens |
|---|---|---|
| Default Paper | Late filing, late notification or late payment penalties totalling £500 or less | On the papers, unless you ask in writing for a hearing, which the tribunal must then hold. HMRC's statement of case within 42 days; any reply must reach the tribunal within 30 days of HMRC sending theirs |
| Basic | Most other penalty appeals, and applications to appeal late | A short hearing, usually by video. No formal statement of case, but HMRC send a statement of reasons and the bundle within 42 days, and you then have 14 days to send any written response |
| Standard | Disputes about how much tax is due | HMRC's statement of case within 60 days, then lists of documents, witness statements and a hearing |
| Complex | Large sums, complex evidence or an important principle | As Standard, but the loser may have to pay the winner's costs unless you opt out in writing within 28 days of receiving the allocation notice |
Otherwise each side normally pays its own costs, unless the tribunal finds a side acted unreasonably (categories and costs).
Grounds Of Appeal: An Outline
Your grounds tell the tribunal and HMRC what the dispute is about, and they set the limits of the case. Facts in your own words are enough: the rules ask for "the grounds for making the appeal", and the tribunal's guidance for "any facts or law that you rely upon". A common layout, in the form's box or on a separate sheet:
- Heading: [Grounds of appeal of [your name] against [the decision or decisions] dated [date]].
- Each decision: [what HMRC decided, the tax year or period, and the amount].
- Numbered grounds, one issue each: [a fact or figure HMRC got wrong, with the correct one], or [the legal test or provision they applied, and why you say it was wrong].
- The facts you rely on: [short dated statements, in order].
- The law you rely on, if you know it: [the Act and section]. HMRC's guidance shows how HMRC read the law, but it isn't the law. If you don't know the law, the tribunal applies it to the facts you give.
- Your evidence: [the documents you have or can get]. You send them when the tribunal directs.
- The result you want: [such as cancelling the penalty, or reducing the assessment to [figure]].
Points to know:
- Length: a straightforward penalty appeal often needs one paragraph; a more complex case might take one to two pages.
- Who proves what: in an assessment appeal, you must show the amount is wrong, or it stands (section 50(6) TMA 1970), but for a discovery assessment, or one made outside the normal time limit, HMRC must first show they were entitled to make it. In a penalty appeal, HMRC must first show the penalty is valid, then a reasonable excuse is for you to prove; HMRC must prove any careless or deliberate behaviour they allege.
- The tribunal's job: whether the tax or penalty is right in law. It has no general power over complaints about HMRC's conduct or delay.
- Accuracy: you confirm the facts are true, and the tribunal can increase an assessment if it finds you undercharged (section 50(7)).
- Changes: the tribunal can let you amend your grounds; very late changes can be refused.
Our grounds guide has worked examples.
Hearing Checklist
Which items apply depends on your case category (hearing guide).
Before The Hearing
- Diary every direction (the tribunal's instructions and their deadlines). Missing one can get your appeal struck out; if you can't comply in time, ask for more time before the deadline.
- Complex case: the costs opt-out has to be made in writing within 28 days of receiving the allocation notice.
- Default Paper case: any reply must reach the tribunal within 30 days of the date HMRC sent their statement of case, with a copy to HMRC. You can ask in it for a hearing.
- Basic case: you have 14 days to send any written response to HMRC's statement of reasons and bundle; the directions give the exact date.
- Standard or Complex case: send your list of documents within 42 days of HMRC's statement of case.
- Witness statement, if directed: numbered paragraphs in date order, facts you know yourself, signed with "I believe the facts stated in this witness statement are true". It is taken as read.
- Bundle (the indexed, page-numbered documents used at the hearing): the directions say who prepares it, and it may be you. A PDF bundle should be searchable; the tribunal can't receive emails over 36MB.
- Skeleton argument, if directed: the facts, why you say HMRC are wrong, and where the evidence is in the bundle.
- Ask early, in writing, for adjustments, an interpreter or privacy: hearings are normally public. You'll usually get at least 14 days' notice of the hearing.
- Can't attend? Apply to postpone as early as you can, with evidence.
- Video hearing: test your connection, and have the bundle printed or on a second screen.
On The Day
- Attend: if you don't, the case can be decided without you.
- Bring the bundle, your witness statement and notes of your key points.
- Expect a judge, perhaps a specialist member, and HMRC's representative. A friend or relative can come, and with the tribunal's permission help present your case.
- Address the judge as "Sir", "Madam" or "Judge".
- The usual order: opening outlines, evidence and questions (cross-examination), then closing submissions.
- Listen to each question, answer what was asked, and say if you don't understand or don't know.
After The Hearing
- GOV.UK says the written decision usually arrives within 12 weeks of the hearing.
- No full written reasons in the decision notice? The tribunal must receive your written request within 14 days of the date it sent the notice, and you must make that request before applying for permission to appeal.
- An appeal to the Upper Tribunal is on a point of law only. Apply to the First-tier Tribunal for permission (form T247) within 56 days of the date it sent the decision notice or, if later, the full written reasons. If it grants permission, your notice of appeal (form FTC1) must reach the Upper Tribunal within one month of the date the permission was sent; if it refuses, your application must reach the Upper Tribunal within one month of the date the refusal was sent. The costs risk is greater there.
- A procedural problem, such as a hearing notice that never reached you: an application to set the decision aside must reach the tribunal within 28 days of the date it sent the decision.
Our guide to what happens after the decision covers each step.
Where To Get Free Help
The clock doesn't stop while you look. The tribunal's guidance says you may have to appeal before you have found a representative, and can tell the tribunal once you have one.
- TaxAid: free advice and casework, in most cases for people earning under £30,500 (since July 2025 including the former Tax Help for Older People); not corporation tax or tax credits. Helpline 0345 120 3779, Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm; replies to its online form can take up to ten working days.
- Advocate: the Bar's pro bono charity looks for volunteer barristers to advise, draft skeleton arguments or represent you at a hearing, but not to prepare paperwork. Its financial criteria are strict, it needs at least three weeks, and you don't need to wait for a hearing date to apply.
- LITRG: the Low Incomes Tax Reform Group's free guides to the tribunal; no individual advice.
- Citizens Advice: signposting, and referrals to TaxAid for people on a low income; no tax advice itself.
- Law Centres, LawWorks clinics and Support Through Court: free initial advice or non-legal support, but rarely on tax. GOV.UK points tribunal users to Support Through Court's helpline (03000 810 006) for remote hearings.
- HMRC's extra support: help dealing with HMRC if your health or circumstances make it difficult, not help with the appeal.
- The tribunal office (0300 303 5857): procedure, not legal advice.
Our representation guide explains each service and how to check a paid adviser. An HMRC review and settlement or alternative dispute resolution can also end a dispute for free.
For more on every step, see our step-by-step appeal guide and the complete dispute timeline.
This kit is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal or tax advice. For advice specific to your situation, consult a qualified tax adviser, accountant, or solicitor.