HMRC Refused Your Loss Relief? Trading Losses, Share Losses And How To Appeal
HMRC can refuse relief for a business loss set against your salary or pension if the trade wasn't 'commercial', or for a share loss that doesn't qualify. What the tests mean, what the tribunal looks at, and how to appeal: to HMRC first, within 30 days of the decision.
If HMRC have refused the business or share loss you set against your salary, pension or other income, the decision usually comes in a closure notice: HMRC's formal conclusion at the end of an enquiry (a formal check) into your tax return. A common reason is that the business wasn't "commercial": not run on a commercial basis, or not run with a view to profit.
You can appeal. The appeal goes to HMRC, not the tribunal: write to HMRC within 30 days of the date the closure notice was issued, saying which of its conclusions you disagree with and why. Count from the date on the notice, not the day it arrived.
A refusal doesn't usually wipe the loss out: a business loss still carries forward against that business's profits, a share loss against capital gains.
HMRC refused a claim made outside your return, or took back relief already given by an assessment? The same 30 days applies. Still answering HMRC's questions? There is nothing to appeal yet, but the evidence below matters now.
On this page:
Which Loss Relief Did You Claim?
Tax law calls a business a "trade", and setting a trading loss against other income is called "sideways" relief. The relief you claimed decides the rules:
| Relief | What it does | Claim by | Main restrictions |
|---|---|---|---|
| Against other income ("sideways" relief), s.64 ITA 2007 | A trading loss against your income of the loss year, the year before, or both; any unused part may then go against capital gains, your profits on selling assets (s.261B TCGA 1992) | one year after the 31 January following the tax year of the loss | Commerciality (s.66); farming losses (s.67); the cap (s.24A); non-active sole traders (s.74A); avoidance (s.74ZA) |
| Early years, s.72 | A loss in the first 4 tax years of a trade, against your income of the 3 tax years before the loss year | one year after the 31 January following the tax year of the loss | A stricter commerciality test (s.74); the cap (s.24A) |
| Carry forward, s.83 | Against later profits of the same trade only | 4 years after the end of the loss year (s.43 TMA 1970) | Not restricted by the commerciality or farming rules, or by the cap |
| Share loss relief, ss.131 and 132 | A capital loss on shares you subscribed for in a qualifying trading company, against your income of the loss year, the year before, or both | one year after the 31 January following the tax year of the loss | The company and share conditions (s.131, s.134); the cap, except on Enterprise Investment Scheme (EIS) and Seed Enterprise Investment Scheme (SEIS) shares (s.24A(7)(d)) |
To illustrate: a loss made in the 2025/26 tax year must be claimed against other income by 31 January 2028 (section 64(5)).
A loss from letting property can go against other income only if it has a "capital allowances connection" or the business has a "relevant agricultural connection", and then only the part that comes from capital allowances or agricultural expenses, for the loss year or the next one (sections 120 and 122 ITA 2007); the rest is carried forward against that business's profits. For other property disputes, see property income appeals.
Why HMRC Refuse Relief Against Your Other Income
Numbers in square brackets, like [70], are paragraph numbers in the decision cited, so you can find the passage and refer to it in your own appeal.
A refusal under the commerciality or farming rules below also stops the unused loss going against capital gains. It doesn't stop you carrying the loss forward against the same trade's future profits (section 83(3)): as the tribunal said in Macdonald v HMRC [2025] UKFTT 495 (TC), the commerciality rule "simply limits the options available for managing trading losses" ([70]).
Is It A Trade At All?
Relief needs a trade carried on in the year (section 64(1)), so HMRC may say there was only a hobby or an investment, and no trading loss at all. Their manual calls whether a trade exists "a question of fact" (BIM85705). See also when a hobby becomes a business.
The Commerciality Test: Two Questions For Every Year
Section 66 allows no relief against other income "unless the trade is commercial": carried on throughout the year both "on a commercial basis" and "with a view to the realisation of profits of the trade". These are two separate questions, and the business must pass both (Macdonald [72]).
Each tax year is tested afresh (Macdonald [77]). From the 2024/25 tax year, the test covers the whole tax year. For the 2023/24 tax year and earlier, it covered the "basis period": broadly, the accounting year whose profits were taxed in that tax year.
A commercial basis is objective: was the business run the way a serious business of that type would be? The tribunal quoted an earlier High Court decision's distinction "between the serious trader who, whatever his shortcomings in skill, experience or capital, is seriously interested in profit, and the amateur or dilettante" ([80]). Years of losses don't by themselves mean a business isn't run on a commercial basis, and profit "need not be the predominant aim" ([94]).
A view to profit is subjective, about what you actually intended: "a real and serious intention to make a profit" ([105]). A reasonable expectation of profit counts automatically (section 66(3)), but isn't required. How likely profit was, and how soon, can be evidence of the intention ([114]).
In Macdonald, an estate owner's pheasant and partridge shoot had keepers, budgets reviewed against results, annual targets and twice-yearly meetings with the accountants. The tribunal accepted it was run on a commercial basis and was "not a mere hobby" ([92]). But it had made a tax loss in every year but one for more than 15 years: "not simply a case of being 'temporarily blown off course'" ([111]). With no view to profit, relief was refused.
What Evidence Answers Them
Evidence weighed in Macdonald or listed in HMRC's manuals includes:
- a business plan, forecasts and budgets made at the time, and how results compared;
- costs compared year on year, and prices compared with similar businesses;
- separate records and accounts, and advice from an accountant;
- a record of the time spent (it also matters for the hours rule below);
- what changed when losses continued: officers "are justified in pointing to past results" (BIM85710).
HMRC also look for a private reason (a hobby, personal enjoyment, paying personal costs or raising an asset's value: BIM85710) and for costs that sales could never cover (BIM85735). See gathering your evidence.
One Business Or Several?
The tests apply trade by trade, so how your activities are grouped can decide the claim. In Thorne v HMRC [2016] UKUT 349 (TCC), the First-tier Tribunal judged a horse-breeding activity and an asparagus business together because one return made one combined claim; the Upper Tribunal said that was the wrong test ([26]) and sent the case back for a fresh hearing.
Whether the asparagus growing was farming mattered: all UK farming by one person is one trade (section 9(2) ITTOIA 2005), but market gardening isn't farming for that rule (Thorne [23]).
The other way round, if a trade is part of a larger undertaking, the view to profit is judged on the whole undertaking's profits (section 66(4)). In Macdonald, the tribunal accepted HMRC's argument that the shoot and the rest of the estate were "separate activities, which happen to share a location" ([122]).
Early Years Relief: A Stricter Test
Early years relief has a stricter test (section 74(2)): as well as a commercial basis, the trade must be run so that profits could reasonably be expected in the year "or within a reasonable time afterwards", judged objectively. HMRC's manual suggests "a fairly short period of say a year or so" (BIM85735), but the Act gives no figure.
Farming And Market Gardening
A farm or market garden gets no relief against other income if it made a loss, before capital allowances (tax relief for spending on things like machinery), in each of the previous 5 tax years (section 67(2)). A profit before capital allowances in any of those years breaks the run, and HMRC's manual says the year the trade starts isn't counted (BIM85625).
The rule doesn't apply if the trade forms part of, and is ancillary to (supports), a larger trading undertaking; if it started within the 5 tax years before the current one; or if it passes the competent farmer test in section 68 (section 67(3)).
That test asks two questions about this year's activities. Would a competent farmer reasonably expect them to become profitable at some stage? And, had they been carried on at the beginning of the run of losses, could a competent farmer not reasonably have expected profit until after this year? In Naghshineh v HMRC [2022] EWCA Civ 19, the Court of Appeal adopted that framing from Scambler v HMRC [2017] UKUT 1 (TCC) (Naghshineh [68]).
The second question "does not test the competence of the individual farmer" ([81]), and the rule isn't just for hobby farmers: the Act's "hobby" sub-heading is only "a way-marker" ([42]). The farmer in Naghshineh, found to have intended a commercial, profitable farm, still lost: without evidence answering the right question, the claims "were doomed to failure" ([80]). In Scambler, dairy farmers hit by low milk prices also failed: a competent farmer would need "a positive belief" that the price would stay below a profitable level for the whole period, and unpredictable prices weren't enough ([65], [69]).
Caps, Hours, Avoidance And The Cash Basis
The cap. Relief against other income for trade, property and share losses (except on EIS and SEIS shares), with some other reliefs, can't exceed £50,000 in a tax year or, if more, 25% of your adjusted total income: total income with some adjustments for pension contributions and payroll giving (section 24A; HS204).
Hours. A sole trader personally spending less than an average of 10 hours a week on the trade's commercial activities is "non-active", and relief against other income and gains is capped at £25,000 a year (section 74A; section 74C). Relief given for hours not in fact worked can be taken back by assessment (section 74C(5)).
Avoidance. There is no relief against other income or gains for a loss connected with arrangements you are party to where cutting your tax through that relief is a main purpose (section 74ZA). HMRC's manual says this has "no relevance for the vast majority of taxpayers", and the loss can still be carried forward (BIM85762).
The cash basis (profits worked out from money in and out): for the 2023/24 tax year and earlier, a cash basis trader couldn't set a loss against other income or gains, but could still carry it forward or, for a loss in the last 12 months of trading, carry it back against the same trade's profits (section 74E, since repealed; BIM85010). From the 2024/25 tax year, that bar has gone.
Limited partners, members of limited liability partnerships and partners who spend little time in the trade face extra restrictions (HS227, section 7); for partnership procedure, see partnership tax appeals.
Share Losses And Negligible Value Claims
A loss on shares is normally a capital loss, usable only against capital gains. Share loss relief lets you set it against income instead, for shares you subscribed for (bought new from the company) in a qualifying trading company, which can include SEIS shares, and for shares with EIS relief (section 131(2)). The loss must come from an arm's length sale (on normal commercial terms), a distribution in a winding up, the shares' entire loss, or a negligible value claim (section 131(3)). For shares without EIS relief, the company must have met the conditions in section 134: broadly, that it was unquoted and within a gross assets limit when it issued the shares, and met the trading and independence requirements for the 6 years before the disposal, or since it began if less (HS286 explains them).
A negligible value claim (section 24 TCGA 1992) is for shares you still own that became of negligible value (worth next to nothing) while you owned them: you are treated as selling and buying them back at that value, so the loss counts for tax. After dissolution no negligible value claim is possible, but none is needed: dissolution is itself a disposal, so the loss arises in that tax year (section 24(1); HS286). An earlier loss year needs a claim made before dissolution.
The claim has no time limit of its own, but the deemed sale happens when HMRC receive it (HS286), unless you name an earlier time when you owned the shares and they were already of negligible value. That time can be no more than 2 years before the start of the tax year in which you claim (section 24(2)(b)). The tax year of the deemed sale is the loss year, so it fixes the share loss relief deadline and which years' income the loss can reduce.
The capital loss must also be notified to HMRC within 4 years after the end of the tax year it relates to (section 16(2A) TCGA 1992). For tokens, see crypto tax appeals; for the EIS or SEIS relief itself, EIS and SEIS appeals.
How To Appeal
Where The Decision Came From
A claim in your return. HMRC's enquiry covers any claim in your return (section 9A(4) TMA 1970) and ends with a closure notice amending it (section 28A). You appeal in writing to HMRC within 30 days of the date it was issued (section 31; section 31A). A partial closure notice on the loss alone starts its own clock, and if an enquiry drags on you can ask the tribunal to direct HMRC to close it.
A claim made outside your return, such as a claim to carry a loss back: HMRC's enquiry under Schedule 1A TMA 1970 ends with a closure notice stating their conclusions (paragraphs 5 and 7). You appeal in writing to the officer who issued it, within 30 days of its issue (Schedule 1A, paragraph 9).
Relief already given can be taken back by a discovery assessment, made when HMRC find that it "is or has become excessive" (section 29(1)(c)), normally within 4 years of the end of the tax year, or 6 years if the loss of tax was careless (longer if deliberate). You appeal to HMRC within 30 days of the assessment (discovery assessments).
After Your Appeal To HMRC: Review Or Tribunal
After you appeal, you can ask HMRC for a review (a fresh look by a different officer) or notify your appeal to the tribunal without one (sections 49A(2) and 49D TMA 1970). If HMRC offer a review, you have 30 days to accept it or notify the tribunal; otherwise the appeal is treated as settled on HMRC's view (section 49C(4)), and after that you can notify the tribunal only with its permission (section 49H(3)). If you disagree with the review's conclusions, you have 30 days from the date of the review letter to notify the tribunal (section 49G(5)(a)). See HMRC internal review, appealing to the tribunal, form T240 and late appeals.
Paying The Tax While You Appeal
If a closure notice amending your return, or an assessment, charges more tax, you can apply to HMRC within 30 days of it to postpone the disputed amount (section 55 TMA 1970). Postponing doesn't stop interest: if the tax turns out to be due, interest runs from the original due date. A refused claim made outside your return charges no tax, so there is nothing to postpone. See postponing payment.
Who Has To Prove What
You must prove you qualify: "the burden is on the taxpayer to show that the statutory conditions for the relief are met" (Scambler [63]), on the balance of probabilities (more likely than not). On a discovery assessment, HMRC must first show it was validly made (the split burden). Grounds of appeal answer the notice's conclusions (closure notice appeals).
If The Tribunal Refuses Relief
The Upper Tribunal doesn't rehear the evidence: it steps in only for an error of law (a legal mistake), such as applying the wrong test, as in Thorne, or a finding "based on a false legal premise", as in Naghshineh ([78]). You ask the First-tier Tribunal for permission to appeal within 56 days of the date it sends its decision, or its full written reasons if later: see Upper Tribunal appeals and when you can challenge the tribunal's findings.
What To Do Now
- Find your deadline. Check the date the closure notice, assessment or any penalty was issued and count 30 days from each. Missed it? See late appeals.
- Identify what was refused: the relief, the section HMRC relied on (section 66, 67, 74, 24A, 74A or 74ZA, or the share loss conditions) and every tax year the notice covers.
- Write to HMRC with your appeal, setting out the conclusions you disagree with and why (writing grounds of appeal).
- If extra tax is charged, you can apply to postpone it within 30 days.
- Gather evidence year by year for each question; for farming, evidence aimed at the competent farmer question.
- Choose between an HMRC review and notifying your appeal to the tribunal without a review, and note each step's deadline.
- Check that the loss is still recorded to carry forward against the same trade's profits, and keep other claims within their limits: for relief against other income, early years relief and share loss relief, within one year of the 31 January after the end of the tax year in which the loss was made; for carry-forward and terminal loss claims (when a trade stops), 4 years after the end of the loss year. Overpayment relief can't rescue a missed or mistaken claim (when relief is not given).
- Worthless shares you still own: the negligible value timing rules decide which tax year the loss falls in, and so the share loss relief deadline.
Key Legislation And Resources
Legislation
- Section 64 ITA 2007—trade loss relief against general income ("sideways" relief)
- Section 66 ITA 2007—no relief unless the trade is commercial
- Section 67 and section 68 ITA 2007—farming and market gardening: the run of losses and the competent farmer test
- Section 72 and section 74 ITA 2007—early years relief and its stricter test
- Section 24A ITA 2007—the cap on reliefs against general income
- Section 74A and section 74C ITA 2007—non-active sole traders
- Section 74ZA ITA 2007—no relief for tax-generated losses
- Section 74E ITA 2007, as it stood on 5 April 2024—the old cash basis bar, repealed from the 2024/25 tax year
- Section 83 ITA 2007—carry-forward trade loss relief
- Section 89 ITA 2007—terminal loss relief
- Section 120 and section 122 ITA 2007—property losses against general income
- Section 131, section 132 and section 134 ITA 2007—share loss relief and qualifying trading companies
- Section 9 ITTOIA 2005—farming treated as one trade
- Section 16 TCGA 1992—notifying a capital loss
- Section 24 TCGA 1992—negligible value claims
- Section 261B TCGA 1992—trade losses set against capital gains
- Section 9A TMA 1970—enquiries into returns
- Section 28A TMA 1970—closure notices
- Section 29 TMA 1970—discovery assessments
- Section 31 and section 31A TMA 1970—appeals to HMRC
- Section 43 TMA 1970—the general time limit for claims
- Section 49A TMA 1970—reviews and notifying appeals to the tribunal
- Section 55 TMA 1970—postponing tax during an appeal
- Schedule 1A TMA 1970—claims made outside a return: enquiries (paragraph 5), closure notices (paragraph 7) and appeals (paragraph 9)
- Schedule 1AB TMA 1970, paragraph 2—when overpayment relief is not given
HMRC Guidance
- BIM85010—the types of trade loss relief, and the old cash basis bar
- BIM85705—whether a trade exists, and what a commercial basis means
- BIM85710—the view to profit and a reasonable expectation of profit
- BIM85735—early years relief's stricter test
- BIM85625—farming: counting the run of losses
- BIM85640—farming: the competent farmer test and the evidence HMRC expect
- BIM85761 and BIM85762—tax-generated losses
- CG13125, CG13130 and CG13145—negligible value claims: the conditions, the date of the claim and valuation
- VCM70000—share loss relief
GOV.UK Guidance
- HS227 Losses (2026)—HMRC's helpsheet on trading loss claims
- HS286 Negligible value claims and Income Tax losses on shares (2026)—share loss relief and negligible value claims
- HS204 Limit on Income Tax reliefs (2026)—the cap on reliefs
On This Site
- HMRC Enquiries And Closure Notices—how an enquiry runs and ends
- Understanding Your Appeal Rights—why the appeal goes to HMRC first
- HMRC's Internal Review—the review and its acceptance window
- How To Appeal To The Tax Tribunal and Form T240—notifying your appeal to the tribunal
- Missed The Deadline? Late Appeals—if your time to appeal has passed
- Postponing Payment During An Appeal—section 55 TMA 1970
- HMRC Penalties Explained—a penalty for an inaccurate claim, and appealing it
- Discovery Assessments—relief taken back, and the split burden of proof
- Writing Your Grounds Of Appeal—what to put in your appeal
- Preparing For Your Tax Tribunal Hearing—evidence and the hearing
- Appealing To The Upper Tribunal and Edwards v Bairstow—appealing further on an error of law
- HMRC's Nudge Letters—when a hobby becomes a business
- Appealing HMRC On Rental Income—property disputes
- Partnership Tax Appeals—partnership procedure
- Crypto Tax Appeals—tokens, including negligible value claims
- EIS And SEIS Relief Appeals—when HMRC refuse or withdraw investment relief
- HMRC Determinations And Overpayment Relief—overpayment relief and its limits
- The Complete Timeline Of A UK Tax Dispute—the whole process
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal or tax advice. For advice specific to your situation, consult a qualified tax adviser, accountant, or solicitor.