HMRC Says Your Sales Should Have Had VAT? How To Challenge A VAT Liability Decision
HMRC say sales you treated as zero-rated, reduced-rated or exempt should have had VAT at 20%. How the tribunal decides the rate, one supply or several, who must prove it, and your 30 days to appeal or accept a review.
HMRC say sales you treated as zero-rated, reduced-rated or exempt should have borne VAT at 20%, and the bill may reach back years. The letter is usually an assessment under section 73 VATA 1994 at the end of a compliance check (HMRC's check of your VAT records). Most disputes like this are about the principle, not the arithmetic: which rate the law gives your supply.
You have 30 days from the date on the decision letter to appeal straight to the tax tribunal, or 30 days from the date of the letter offering it to accept HMRC's review. For VAT there is no appeal to HMRC first. Writing informally to ask HMRC to think again, or HMRC restating their view, does not restart the clock (ARTG3041).
The tribunal will usually hear the appeal only once the disputed VAT is paid or deposited, unless HMRC or the tribunal accept that paying would cause you hardship. You can file the appeal first and deal with payment or hardship alongside it (paying while you appeal). If your quarrel is with the size of the figure or the assessment's time limits, see VAT assessment appeals. Where your prices did not add VAT, the VAT is normally treated as included in what you charged, not added on top (section 19(2)).
On this page:
- Which Decision Have You Received?
- How The Law Decides The Rate
- One Supply Or Several?
- Borderline Products
- Who Has To Prove What
- Appealing To The Tribunal Or Accepting A Review
- What To Do Now
| Your situation | What HMRC's decision is | Time limit | Pay first? |
|---|---|---|---|
| HMRC say sales you didn't charge VAT on (or charged at 5%) were standard-rated | An assessment under section 73 | 30 days from the letter to appeal, or 30 days to accept a review | Yes, unless hardship |
| HMRC have given you a written ruling on supplies you are already making | A liability decision you can appeal | 30 days from the letter to appeal, or 30 days to accept a review | If it sets an amount of VAT, unless hardship |
| You charged 20%, think you shouldn't have, and HMRC refused your repayment claim | A refused claim under section 80 | 30 days from the refusal to appeal, or 30 days to accept a review | No |
| You are a business customer of the supplier HMRC ruled on | You may have your own right to a review or appeal | 30 days from becoming aware of the decision | Depends on the decision |
A repayment claim itself must be made within 4 years of the end of the VAT period concerned: that is the claim's limit, separate from the time to appeal its refusal.
Which Decision Have You Received?
The tribunal can hear only the VAT appeals listed in section 83 VATA 1994, so what HMRC have decided matters. See your appeal rights for the general picture.
An Assessment After A Compliance Check
If HMRC think your returns were wrong, they may assess the VAT due "to the best of their judgment" (section 73(1)). The appeal lies against the assessment and the VAT chargeable on the supply (section 83(1)(p) and (b)). Best judgment, time limits and disputes about the figure are covered in VAT assessment appeals.
A Refused Repayment Claim
The reverse dispute: you charged VAT, now think the supply was zero-rated or exempt, and claim it back. HMRC must credit output tax (the VAT you charge on sales) that was "not output tax due" (section 80(1)), within 4 years (section 80(4)).
HMRC can refuse if repaying would "unjustly enrich" you (section 80(3)): broadly, where your customers bore the VAT in the price. A loss your business shows it suffered because of the mistake about VAT is taken into account, but only up to the amount you prove (section 80(3B) and (3C)). A refusal is appealed under section 83(1)(t), and there is no pay-first rule for it. The Morrisons case below began this way.
A Written Ruling, Or A Clearance
A written liability decision about supplies you are already making is generally appealable under section 83(1)(b), and the letter should offer a review. A non-statutory clearance (HMRC's written view of a transaction) about a supply not yet made is different: HMRC say no appealable decision can be given before a supply is made (ARTG3041; ONSCG9200).
If you want HMRC's view in advance, VAT Notice 700, section 1.5, points you to a clearance. You must show "a genuine uncertainty" about how the law applies, and you can rely on the answer only if your information was accurate and complete and you carry out the transaction exactly as you described it; it "applies only to the customer it was issued to" (clearance guidance).
Story Terrace Ltd v HMRC [2025] UKFTT 1554 (TC) shows the ruling route. The company, which turns customers' life stories into books, got a liability ruling for one VAT return, asked for a review, lost it, and appealed. The tribunal decided only the rate, leaving the amount for later.
When You Are The Customer
If HMRC rule on what your supplier should charge you, you may have your own right to a review or appeal, within 30 days of becoming aware of the decision (section 83B; section 83G(1)). HMRC's guidance expects you to work with the supplier on a common position (ARTG3190).
Only the supplier who accounted for the VAT can claim it back under section 80. For refused input tax, see VAT input tax appeals; for a refund for building work, see DIY housebuilder appeals.
How The Law Decides The Rate
VAT is charged at 20% (section 2(1)) unless a specific provision says otherwise. That is the standard rate, and it is the default. The exceptions are lists in the Act's Schedules:
- Reduced rate (5%): supplies described in Schedule 7A (section 29A).
- Zero rate: supplies described in Schedule 8 (section 30(2)).
- Exempt: supplies described in Part 2 of Schedule 9, unless Part 3 excludes them (section 31(1)).
So a business that says its supply is not standard-rated has to fit it into a specific Group and item of one of those Schedules. Zero-rated and exempt are not the same: zero-rated supplies are still taxable, so the VAT on your costs (input tax) can be recovered, while exempt supplies are not taxable and input tax on them generally cannot (see VAT input tax appeals).
Numbers in square brackets, like [37], are paragraph numbers in the decision cited, so you can find the passage and refer to it in your own appeal.
The words of the Schedules are read strictly. In News Corp UK & Ireland Ltd v HMRC [2023] UKSC 7, where digital editions of newspapers were held not to be zero-rated "newspapers" for the period in dispute, the Supreme Court said: "It is well established that zero-rating provisions must be interpreted strictly because they constitute exemptions to the general principle that all supplies of goods and services for consideration by a taxable person should be subject to VAT. They should not, however, be interpreted so strictly as to deprive the exemption of its intended effect" ([38]).
Is There A Supply At All?
Apart from special cases in Schedule 4, such as some gifts and private use of business goods, something is a supply only if it is done for a consideration, meaning something given in return (section 5(2)(a)). HMRC's manual says there must be "a direct link between the supply made and the consideration given" (VATSC02120).
One Supply Or Several?
Many liability disputes turn on this question. Suppose you sell a package with a zero-rated part and a standard-rated part. If the law treats the package as one supply, the whole of it normally takes one rate, unless a specific rule in the legislation taxes one part differently. If it is several supplies, each part takes its own rate. HMRC's manual says the answer "will always depend on the facts of each case" (VATSC11113).
The Principles
In HMRC v The Honourable Society of Middle Temple [2013] UKUT 250 (TCC), the Upper Tribunal summarised the principles drawn from decisions of the EU Court of Justice in 12 points ([60]). Tribunals still use the summary. The points that matter most here are:
- Every supply is normally "distinct and independent", but a transaction that is a single one "from an economic point of view should not be artificially split".
- You look at the transaction "from the point of view of a typical consumer".
- There is a single supply where elements are "so closely linked" that splitting them would be artificial.
- There is also a single supply where one element is the principal supply and the others are ancillary, sharing its rate. An element is ancillary if, for the customer, it is not "an aim in itself, but is a means of better enjoying the principal service supplied".
- A genuine freedom for the customer to choose whether to have an element, one that "reflects the economic reality of the arrangements", points to separate supplies, as does separate invoicing and pricing "if it reflects the interests of the parties"; neither is decisive.
Middle Temple itself was a loss for the taxpayer: cold water supplied to tenants with their premises was part of a single supply of the property, not a separate zero-rated supply of water.
If It Is One Supply, Which Rate?
The Court of Appeal in HMRC v Gray & Farrar International LLP [2023] EWCA Civ 121, a case about where a matchmaking service was supplied rather than its rate, set out the test tribunals now apply: "The question is what is the predominant element in what the typical consumer thinks he or she is acquiring" ([42]). The court accepted that "there may be cases where there is no predominant element", and other tests may then help ([48]). Where there is a written agreement, "the starting point, at least normally, is to identify the legal rights and obligations of the parties as a matter of contract" ([56]).
That test won Story Terrace's appeal. HMRC said the company supplied standard-rated ghost-writing; the company said it supplied zero-rated books. The tribunal started with the contract and decided that "the typical consumer would regard the provision of the book as qualitatively the most important element of the Appellant's supply" ([69]). HMRC's list of VAT appeals does not show an appeal against it, but a First-tier Tribunal decision binds only the parties to it.
If It Is Several, Each Part Takes Its Own Rate
Queenscourt Ltd v HMRC [2026] UKUT 195 (TCC) concerned a KFC franchisee's meal deals. Both sides accepted that a meal deal was a multiple supply. The Upper Tribunal held that "each element of a multiple supply must be analysed separately for VAT purposes", so the dip pots were "separate zero-rated supplies" ([173]). HMRC are seeking permission to appeal to the Court of Appeal, so this may not be the last word (HMRC's list of VAT appeals).
Borderline Products: Food As An Example
Food shows how fine the lines can be. "Food of a kind used for human consumption" is zero-rated, but confectionery is excepted and standard-rated, "not including cakes or biscuits other than biscuits wholly or partly covered with chocolate or some product similar in taste and appearance" (Schedule 8, Group 1). So a cake is zero-rated and a chocolate-covered biscuit is standard-rated.
The Jaffa Cakes decision of 1991 is the best-known example of that line. HMRC's manual records the factors the VAT tribunal weighed: the name, the ingredients, the texture, size, packaging, how they were marketed, how they were eaten, and that a Jaffa cake goes hard when stale, like a cake, rather than soft, like a biscuit. The manual says the tribunal thought they had "enough characteristics of cakes to be accepted as such", so they were zero-rated (VFOOD6260).
Morrisons' dispute over Nakd and Organix fruit and nut bars shows the same kind of test in a modern case, and that a win on the law does not guarantee a win on the facts. Morrisons had charged VAT, claimed it back, and was refused. In WM Morrison Supermarkets PLC v HMRC [2023] UKUT 20 (TCC), the Upper Tribunal held that the first tribunal had gone wrong in law by treating the bars' healthiness and their lack of traditional confectionery ingredients as irrelevant, and sent the case back.
Morrisons lost at the rehearing in 2024, in WM Morrison Supermarkets PLC v HMRC [2024] UKFTT 181 (TC). The tribunal called the question "ultimately a matter of impression" and found the bars were confectionery because of their look, texture, density and taste, as "the informed ordinary person in the street" would see them, reinforced by marketing as sweet snacks and treats ([57]).
Classification turns on fact and degree, so an appeal beyond the First-tier Tribunal needs an error of law, as Morrisons' first appeal had (when the tribunal's findings can be challenged).
Who Has To Prove What
Because the standard rate is the default, the business usually has to prove its supply falls within a Schedule. In Story Terrace the tribunal said: "It is for the Appellant to show that its supplies are zero rated. ... The standard of proof is on the balance of probabilities" ([9]-[10]). The balance of probabilities means more likely than not.
The tribunal decides from the evidence about what the customer actually buys. The tribunals in these cases looked at:
- the contract and terms and conditions, which are normally the starting point;
- invoices, receipts and price lists, including how a package is priced;
- product specifications and recipes;
- samples of the disputed products where they were available, and photographs and packaging;
- marketing, your website and how products are displayed;
- how customers actually order and use what you sell.
At the Morrisons rehearing, the tribunal had no samples of six bars, so "we were unable to form a view on those bars individually", and treated them like the bars it had tasted ([51]). Evidence also needs to be analysed, not just piled up: in Story Terrace, 227 pages of online reviews did not help, because "either party could select the reviews that they said supported their case" ([37]).
For bundles, samples and witness statements, see preparing for your hearing. Grounds of appeal that name the Schedule, Group and item you rely on are covered in writing grounds of appeal.
Appealing To The Tribunal Or Accepting A Review
For VAT you either appeal straight to the tribunal within 30 days of the decision letter (section 83G), or accept HMRC's offer of a review within 30 days (section 83C). A review is a fresh look by an HMRC officer not involved in the decision.
HMRC then have 45 days to give their conclusions, and if they don't, the decision is treated as upheld (section 83F(6) and (8)). You then have 30 days to appeal to the tribunal (section 83G(3) and (5)). The HMRC internal review guide explains both routes.
To file, see how to appeal to the tax tribunal and the notice of appeal form; whether you could face HMRC's costs if you lose depends on your case's track. A late appeal needs the tribunal's permission (section 83G(6)): see late appeals.
For an assessment or a liability decision that sets an amount payable, the tribunal will not hear the appeal until the VAT is paid or deposited, unless paying would cause hardship (section 84(3) and (3B)). You ask HMRC first, then the tribunal: see the hardship test. Hardship only lets the appeal go ahead without paying first: if you lose, you can be charged interest on the disputed VAT until it is paid (GOV.UK; see also interest on unpaid tax).
A wrong-rate error can also bring an inaccuracy penalty, which has its own appeal: see VAT penalties.
When HMRC Changed Their Mind
If HMRC once accepted your treatment and have now reversed it, that can feel unfair. HMRC's view is that the tribunal "has no jurisdiction to consider arguments on grounds of fairness" (ARTG3041; see the limits of the tribunal's powers). In Queenscourt, the Upper Tribunal said the first tribunal had gone wrong in law in the way it decided it could hear a legitimate expectation argument (that HMRC should be held to what they led the business to expect). Because the outcome did not turn on it, the Upper Tribunal left open whether the tribunal can hear such an argument in an appeal like that one ([151], [158], [170]).
Quoting an earlier Upper Tribunal decision, it said the uncertainty "would clearly benefit from clarification, either by legislation or by a decision of a superior court" ([142]). Such arguments generally go to judicial review (a High Court challenge to how HMRC acted, not to the VAT itself), which must be brought promptly and in any event within 3 months, so get advice quickly.
What To Do Now
- Find the date on the decision letter and diary the deadline: the 30 days to appeal begin with that date, so count the letter's date as day 1.
- Work out which decision you have: an assessment, a written ruling, a refused repayment claim, or a decision about your supplier.
- Identify the Schedule, Group and item you say your supply falls within.
- Gather the contract, invoices, specifications, samples, packaging and marketing for every disputed product or service.
- Decide whether to accept HMRC's review or appeal straight to the tribunal; the time limits apply either way.
- Pay or deposit the VAT, or apply to HMRC on hardship grounds, and file the appeal on time either way.
- Check whether customers or suppliers are affected, and whether a penalty letter needs its own appeal. If HMRC assess later periods too, each assessment has its own 30 days to appeal.
- For future supplies, note that HMRC's view can be sought through a non-statutory clearance, and that a qualified adviser can help with how to treat sales while the dispute runs.
Key Legislation And Resources
Legislation
- Section 2 VATA 1994—the standard rate
- Section 4 VATA 1994—the charge to VAT and taxable supplies
- Section 5 VATA 1994—what counts as a supply
- Section 29A VATA 1994 and Schedule 7A—the reduced rate
- Section 30 VATA 1994 and Schedule 8—zero-rating
- Section 31 VATA 1994 and Schedule 9—exemption
- Section 73 VATA 1994—assessments
- Section 80 VATA 1994—repayment claims and unjust enrichment
- Section 83 VATA 1994—the decisions you can appeal
- Section 83B, section 83C, section 83F and section 83G VATA 1994—reviews and the time to appeal
- Section 84 VATA 1994—paying or depositing the VAT, and hardship
Key Cases
- News Corp UK & Ireland Ltd v HMRC [2023] UKSC 7—zero-rating read strictly, but not so strictly as to defeat its purpose
- HMRC v The Honourable Society of Middle Temple [2013] UKUT 250 (TCC)—the Upper Tribunal's summary of the single and multiple supply principles
- HMRC v Gray & Farrar International LLP [2023] EWCA Civ 121—the predominant element from the typical consumer's point of view, starting with the contract
- Queenscourt Ltd v HMRC [2026] UKUT 195 (TCC)—each element of a multiple supply takes its own rate; HMRC seeking permission to appeal
- Story Terrace Ltd v HMRC [2025] UKFTT 1554 (TC)—books, not ghost-writing; the burden of proof on the business
- WM Morrison Supermarkets PLC v HMRC [2023] UKUT 20 (TCC) and [2024] UKFTT 181 (TC)—fruit and nut bars: an error of law at the Upper Tribunal, then confectionery at the rehearing
HMRC Guidance
- VATSC11113—single and multiple supplies
- VATSC02120—supply for consideration
- VFOOD6260—the borderline between cakes and biscuits
- ARTG3041—which VAT decisions can be appealed
- ARTG3190—reviews and appeals by third parties
- ONSCG9200—appealable VAT decisions from clearance teams
- VAT Notice 700, section 1.5—getting HMRC's view of a transaction
- Non-statutory clearance service guidance—how to ask for a clearance and when you can rely on it
- List of VAT appeals updates—HMRC's list of VAT cases under appeal
On This Site
- VAT Assessment Appeals—best judgment, time limits and the size of the figure
- VAT Input Tax Appeals—refused input tax, and why zero-rated and exempt differ
- VAT Penalties And Appeals—inaccuracy penalties for a wrong rate
- Postponing Payment During An Appeal—paying or depositing VAT, and hardship
- HMRC's Internal Review—the VAT review route
- How To Appeal To The Tax Tribunal—filing your appeal
- Writing Your Grounds Of Appeal—what to put in your appeal
- Tribunal Tracks And Costs—which track your case is on, and the risk of costs
- Settling Your Tax Tribunal Case—agreeing a settlement with HMRC
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal or tax advice. For advice specific to your situation, consult a qualified tax adviser, accountant, or solicitor.